Thursday, December 25, 2008
Ciudad Presidente Kennedy
Due to its unpleasant nature, there have been several occasions when certain citizen groups have tried to lead campaigns to change the town name. Interestingly in the 1960s, there was a group of citizens who led a newspaper campaign to change the name to Ciudad Presidente Kennedy, meaning President Kennedy City. The citizen group was reacting to a pro-communist mayor of our town at the time. By renaming the city, this group wanted to imply that the town was a land of democracy and freedom. However, due to the fact that the name was not native to Peru and Kennedy had little to due with the development of the town, the majority of citizens did not want to change the name. Of course, what makes this story even more interesting is that President Kennedy was the visionary and founder of Peace Corps. While our town wasn’t ready to accept Kennedy at the time, only a few decades later they have warmly welcomed his vision and taken in these two volunteers as one of their own.
“But if life will not be easy, it will be rich and satisfying. For every young American who participates in the Peace Corps—who works in a foreign land—will know that he or she is sharing in the great common task of bringing to man that decent way of life which is the foundation of freedom and a condition of peace.”
--President John F. Kennedy
On March 1, 1961, President John F. Kennedy issued Executive Order #10924, establishing the Peace Corps as a new agency within the Department of State.
Festival de la Primavera
Below are some pictures of the parade and also a short video of a horse show we saw there. The horses are trained to do all kinds of trotting and even dance to the Marinara (unfortunately I couldn’t get the horses dancing the Marinara on camera…).
Gallito Ciego Reservoir
The reservoir that washes up against the lower end of our town is a vast and beautiful body of water, lined by Andean foothills. The hydroelectric dam which rests at the opposite end of the reservoir is commonly known as Gallito Ciego, meaning “blind hen.” Research about building the dam began in the 1960s and construction eventually started in the early 1980s. The dam would result in the flooding of two entire towns (Chungala and Montegrande, which had existed for 331 years) as well as 2/3 of our town, but neither the inhabitants of the area nor the congressmen from Cajamarca protested much to the installation. The residents whose houses were submerged were relocated to a nearby area and awarded several times the amount of land they previously owned as well as a new house.
The dam was built in 1988 as a project of the State with financial backing from a German development bank. It is now managed by a private company hired by the State. Interestingly, the dam does not directly provide electricity to our town, but rather is part of a regional network of hydroelectric plants which distributes the electricity appropriately throughout several departments.
People in our town today look back on the flooding and building of the dam with little regret. They acknowledge that the project sacrificed a few for energy and the better irrigation of lands for the many. However, most of the inhabitants of our town today were not directly affected by the project; only those in Chungala and Montegrande were relocated and today live in another city. Their reactions might be quite different.
The flooding of the valley had both benefits and costs, which are identified below:
Benefits
- Massive hydroelectric energy although it does not supply our town directly
- Greater irrigation access for many farmers in the surrounding valley
- Each relocated citizen was given several times the amount of land they previously owned as well as a new house
- Jobs for the region
- Change in climate. The climate is now cooler, which reduced the mosquito population and helped contribute to the eradication of malaria in the area
- Esthetically pleasing
- Creation of a new tourist attraction
Costs
- Destruction of two towns, Montegrande and Chungala, and the relocation of all inhabitants
- Destruction of 1,000 hectareas of rice land
- Loss of production capacity for 900,000 sacks of rice annually
- Dramatic reduction in population and emigration of human capital
- Flooding of valuable ancient archaeological sites. There are thousands of pre-Incan artifacts buried under the reservoir.
- Disruption of ecosystems including the complete extinction of shrimp and the businesses associated with selling shrimp
- Loss of “molino” (rice mills) industry whose factories were flooded
A second phase of the project was planned and never completed. This phase involved cementing the ground of the reservoir to prevent sediment buildup. However, the project went over budget and could not afford to carry out the second phase. As a result, the river which empties into the reservoir continues to carry large amounts of sediment which slowly builds up and reduces the capacity for water retention. Some citizens worry that the government will decide yet again to expand the reservoir once the sediment reduces the water capacity enough; flooding more land would be cheaper than implementing the second phase of cementation. Another problem with the sediment build-up is that it creates quicksand in certain areas, which is dangerous. There have been a number of deaths due to the quicksand.
Thanksgiving Travels
Reconnect was a great opportunity to reunite with all our friends and swap stories about life in the field. While the mood was generally festive, volunteers were also weighed down by the recent controversial departure of one of our fellow volunteers, Leanna. Milene and I felt particularly saddened as she was a volunteer from our department of Cajamarca and we had gotten to know her pretty well. Volunteers took the opportunity to express their concerns with the Peace Corps administration over Leanna’s firing.
To catch our bus back to site we first went to the capital city of Piura department, also called Piura city. There we had a few hours to get to know the desert city and visit the little-known but incredibly cool artisan town of Catacaos. In Catacaos we perused through dozens of artisan kiosks lining the streets being impressed especially by their ceramics work. From there it was another 8 hour bus ride back to our site in Cajamarca department. Exhausted from a packed trip, we crashed in bed and enjoyed a much-needed sleep in our very own beds.
Peace Corps Reform
On several occasions we held subcommittee sessions on the future of the Peace Corps, with involvement from Brookings experts, the NPCA national leadership, Sen. Harris Wofford (one of the original Peace Corps architects), USAID reps, and some recently returned Peace Corps volunteers. These sessions were quite interesting for me to participate in since at the time I was a soon-to-be Peace Corps volunteer. It was insightful for me to experience the “Washington perspective” of Peace Corps before actually arriving in Peru and experiencing the “local perspective” of Peace Corps.
What I took from those meetings is that many people would like to see a bigger and better Peace Corps, fulfilling the potential that JFK saw when he first created the program in the early 60s. President Kennedy envisioned that 100,000 Americans would volunteer annually in the Peace Corps, creating America’s most vibrant and effective foreign policy tool; today, the number of Peace Corps volunteers stands at 8,000, just half of what it was in its peak during the late 1960s and nowhere near JFK’s original plan. The Peace Corps subcommittee at Brookings advocated at least a doubling of the Peace Corps by 2011, the 50th anniversary of the Peace Corps. With verbal commitments by the next president to double the size of the Peace Corps (with equivalent funding), hopes are high for such a change to take place.
Another topic discussed during these meetings which I found interesting was the necessity for organizational reform within Peace Corps. While Peace Corps is incredibly effective at creating goodwill and understanding between Americans and the people of developing countries, criticisms have been raised that Peace Corps does not do a good enough job improving real conditions on the ground. Part of the problem is that Peace Corps, unlike many other professional development organizations, does not measure its long-term effects in the countries in which it works. There are no longitudinal studies measuring exactly how much family incomes increase, or exactly how much diseases decline, or exactly how much the environment improves in volunteer sites. For this reason, some in the international development community do not consider the Peace Corps to be a “real” development organization. Thus, the belief is that in order to truly propel Peace Corps upwards as America’s most effective foreign policy tool and an effective development organization, it must be expanded quantitatively and improved qualitatively.
My own personal sense of this, based on the limited time I have been serving as a volunteer, is that these criticisms are basically on point. When I was accepted into the Peace Corps back in 2007, I found that during conversations with friends and family, many people were not very aware of Peace Corps’s existence. If they were aware of it, they associated Peace Corps with the 1960s decade, with “hippieism,” and with volunteer drug use. Their notion of Peace Corps is not quite up-to-date. For me, this is a shame, because Peace Corps does such great work and is by far one of America’s best foreign policy tools. Being here, I see how easy it is for Peruvians to look on TV every now and then and see their local news channel reporting something negative about the United States and believing it. People in small towns in foreign countries are disconnected from the complexity of what America is. It is very easy to form over-generalized opinions about America based on the limited information they receive. But as soon as a Peace Corps volunteer is put in the town, ideas begin to change about what America is. Volunteers put a personal face to America. Lengthy conversations between volunteers and people in their sites help to dispel misconceptions and create a genuine dialogue.
So I imagine what things would be like if Peace Corps did have 100,000 volunteers every year and I think the effect would be tremendous. To imagine the effect I see on a small scale through mine and Milene’s daily interactions with people here in our town, multiplied by the hundreds of thousands every year, is inspiring. Especially after 9-11, many Americans are looking for ways to serve their country and I think Peace Corps is one of the best options out there—but its capacity is nowhere near big enough and its presence in general American society is limited. By now it is almost cliché to say that America’s image is suffering in the world and our relations with other countries deteriorating. But the thing about clichés is that they are usually true. As a nation, I don’t think we can afford to ignore this problem, and one of the best solutions I see (albeit biased at the present moment) is to drastically increase the Peace Corps in both size and funding.
The other point raised is Peace Corps’s effectiveness as a development organization. That is, not just bringing about better understanding between America and other countries, but actually making long-lasting impacts in key areas such as education, health, environment and poverty. From my experience here, I have noticed that most volunteers are rather young (in their 20s) with limited work experience in development (including myself). I don’t think that this in and of itself is a major problem, but it just means that volunteers need more institutional structure and guidance to ensure that their projects are well-chosen, effectively managed, and sustainable in the long-run. In Peru, this is hard to guarantee because there are simply not enough trained staff to help manage the multitude of projects that volunteers undertake. In my Small Business Development program, for example, we have one staff who is capable enough to guide and manage projects, but as our program director he is swamped with overseeing 40 or so volunteers and handling all the day-to-day problems that go along with that. He simply does not have the institutional support needed to ensure that projects for all 40 volunteers are carried out successfully. Volunteers are mostly trusted to choose their own projects and carry them out as they see fit. But this brings us back to the problem that most volunteers have limited professional development experience and thus basically do the best they can.
It’s hard for Peace Corps to know if their volunteers are doing a good job in development work unless it somehow studies the changes that happen on the ground in the towns. Currently, volunteers submit reports to their in-country headquarters about three times a year. But these reports are mostly numbers-focused and not what I would call effect-focused. For example, volunteers report how many people in their town listened to a talk they gave on washing hands, or they report how many people attended a seminar on basic accounting practices. So Peace Corps knows how many people we are reaching, but what they do not know is how many people we are affecting and how permanent that affect is. Continuing with the example, although Peace Corps may know that 100 people in my town learned about the importance of washing their hands, they don’t know how many of those people went back home and actually started washing their hands, and more importantly, by how much related diseases declined. This type of information gathering would require far more sophisticated and professional studies. This is problematic, because if Peace Corps does not measure its developoment effectiveness in real terms, there is no way to know if what we are doing is working and if not, how to adjust our strategies as a result. I strongly believe that volunteers do make a real development difference, some more than others depending on experience, motivation etc., but it’s important that Peace Corps becomes more serious about knowing what that difference is that we are making and trying to make our impact a lot more effective.
If you’d like to read more about this whole debate, I am posting links to two articles below, one of which was written by members of our Brookings subcommittee on Peace Corps. Any comments you guys would like to post on these articles or this topic is fully welcomed.
Article 1:
http://devex.com/articles/where-to-go-peace-corps
Article 2:
http://docs.google.com/fileview?id=F.7c399238-0e20-47c1-bf5f-1adfc7f465f3
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
A Fermented Surprise
New Pics Up
We have new pics up at our Picasa Web Album for you to enjoy:
http://picasaweb.google.com/nathanhaft
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
Email Update from the First 4 Months
Dear Family and Friends,
Warm greetings to all of you from both of us here in
Before we go on, because this email will be rather long, we want to give you a few important contact details:
Check our BLOG for updates, photos, info, etc at: www.nateandmilene.blogspot.com
Check our WEB ALBUM for photos and captions: http://picasaweb.google.com/
You can call us at: 011-51-76-976401187 (this is what you would dial from the
You can send us letters or packages at:
Nathan and Milene Haft
Voluntarios de Cuerpo de Paz
Casilla Postal No. 779
SERPOST La Libertad
***Packages must be sent through United States Postal Service, be under 7 pounds, sent in a padded envelope, and have a declared value of under $100.
We'd love to hear from all of you, whether it be through phone, email, internet blog, or letters!
Also, before I forget if there is anyone who I forgot to include on this email list and you think would like to receive our periodic updates, please let me know. On the other hand, if you would like to be removed from our update list, just let me know and we will take you off--we understand and we promise it won't hurt our feelings!
Back to our email update – We arrived in
Yes, this is the same
We spent our first three months in
On August 22, we graduated from training and officially swore in as Peace Corps volunteers with the Charge d'Affaires of the American embassy and other important dignitaries present at the ceremony. We then took a 17-hour bus ride to the department of Cajamarca to permanently move in to our site. [side note: the buses in
To put it briefly, we couldn't be happier with our site assignment and the people we live with here in our town. We feel very comfortable here and I think we were almost meant to be in this town. I've never been too sure about my opinion on destiny but the night before our sight assignments were given to us by Peace Corps administration, I had a bizarrely accurate dream/premonition of my future site. I woke up that morning and explained my entire dream to Milene—that we were going to live in a small town built on a giant blue lake and surrounded by mountains. Although the town was constructed on pillars above the lake, our house was to be on the shore of the lake, according to my dream. In the dream we were on a porch as water lapped up to within a few feet of us. When I explained the dream to my bosses that day, they were extremely shocked to hear such an accurate description of our site without them having told us our assignment yet. Sure enough, when we arrived at site, our town sat exactly on the edge of an enormous blue lake, surrounded by mountains. Our house was one of two homes in town that was located directly on the lake shore. During the rainy season, water comes up to the walls of the home, and although we don't have a porch, we do have a balcony. Oddly enough, as I had dreamed that the town was actually built on the lake, I later found out that the town had previously been located where the lake is now, but was relocated further up the mountain when the government installed a hydro-electric dam and flooded the entire valley, giving rise to a lake exactly where the town used to be.
Beyond supernatural signs, Milene and I are enjoying daily reality here. It is very ´tranquilo´ as they say here, and the constant temperate weather encourages a very laid-back lifestyle. The serenity of the mountains, lake and the breeze trickles down to daily life. Siesta from about 1-4 in the afternoon is a regular occurrence, and many people often spend their afternoons sitting outside their homes and on street corners just chatting with their neighbors. Milene and I have gladly embraced the culture, and we spend many afternoons and evenings reading or sitting out on our balcony relaxing in front of the beautiful view our house has. We often see large birds gliding above us on the balcony, and swooping low within about 20 feet of us. We're starting to pick up yoga as well and I have noticed a significant improvement in my usual back discomfort as a result.
Our host family consists of an elderly mother (74 yrs old!) and several grown children who actually live in a bigger city about an hour from our town. Their family business is in agriculture, and so our backyard is filled with several acres of rice paddies, as well as a small grove of mango, avocado, banana and mandarin trees. We also have a small grape vineyard which is not producing very well and we have taken an interest in solving the grape problem in order to make some of our very own home-made wine. In fact, we have plans to team up with another volunteer in Cajamarca and start our own wine business in
On the work side of things, Milene is off to a good start as a Youth Development Volunteer. She is starting to meet people at the schools and health post and form plans for workshops and youth programs. She is doing a lot of studying of materials which Peace Corps gave her for ideas on creative programs. She recently began a joint program with the health post to go into schools and teach children about healthy living, including talks on hand-washing, brushing teeth, self-esteem, gender equality, etc. However, she is trying to play mostly a supporting role in these first few months so as to understand the town's situation better before trying to propose programs of her own. Our town is a bit more developed than many other volunteer sites in terms of youth programs. They already have in place many of the programs that Peace Corps youth development volunteers would otherwise initiate. However, some of the feedback she has received so far from the town is that there is a need for character or value education, and also guidance for career development.
For me, in the Small Business Development program, I am spending my time getting to know my organizations and the town. I work principally with three groups: a women's weaving association, a shrimp farming business, and a tourism development committee. It's a big deal to ´ganar confianza´ which literally means 'win the confidence' of people in our town because Peace Corps' development strategy is to become friends and integrate into the town before trying to help fix problems they may have. Peruvian culture is such that we can not simply come in to a town and start teaching them things because a) we don´t know enough about their situation to give accurate advice and b) they won't listen to us without us first becoming friends. So I spend most afternoons either at the weaving workshop, out in the shrimp farms, or in meetings with the tourism committee, trying to get to know their associations and the people better. Recently, I began business English classes for the weaving association to prepare for an upcoming artisan fair in
Milene and I visit many local stores and try to engage with as many people as possible in town in order to understand their opinions, lifestyles and needs. We will be focusing on this for three months at the end of which we will submit an exhaustive community diagnostic report with recommendations for future development work.
Well this email has run on to short story length and it is about time to conclude. Plus, the donkeys' hee-hawing outside is reminding me how late it is. For all of you who have made it to the end of this long email, thanks for taking the time hear about our happenings. Thank you all so much for your support, love and friendship, which helps us tremendously being down here on our own.Any time we receive emails or letters it always brightens our day and helps us to feel connected to all our loved ones back in the States. If you feel especially inspired, we are always delighted to receive care packages (for ideas on what to send, check out our blog's wish list).
We hope all is well with you and your families. Until the next time we get internet access, take care.
With Love from
Nathan and Milene
Supernatural Dreams
This post is adapted from the briefer explanation I gave about my dream in the update email to friends and family, posted above.
Assigning sites to volunteers is an interesting process. To provide a little background on the site assignment process, volunteers don’t actually choose which town they want to live in for two years in Peru. We have to be flexible to be placed in any town in
Now, I’m not too sure about my opinion on destiny, but both Milene and I feel that somehow our site assignment was meant to be. The night before our sight assignments were given to us by Peace Corps administration, I had a bizarrely accurate dream of my future site. It is safe to say that this was the craziest form of premonition I have ever experienced. Tension had been building up for weeks before site assignments as volunteers discussed with ever growing anxiety their thoughts and ‘what-ifs’concerning their future sites. I myself was really hoping for some place in the mountains but suspected that somehow I might be placed on the coast. Milene and I discussed with evermore frequency our ideas on where we might end up. Finally the day had come to find out where we would be placed, where we would spend the next two years of our lives.
That night before, I dreamed about our future site. I woke up that morning and explained my entire night’s dream to Milene. In the dream, there was a small town built on top of a lake and supported by giant concrete pillars rising out of the water. The lake and town were surrounded by mountains. Although the town was constructed on pillars above the lake, our house was on the shore of the lake, according to my dream. We were on a porch as water lapped up to within feet of us. Everything was beautiful about the site. The only downside in the dream was that the lake was actually quite dirty. When I explained all this to Milene, she chuckled and said, “Yeah that would be nice, but I don’t think we should get our hopes up.” After all, we both knew that sites with lakes and mountains were nearly unheard of and we had been given the impression by our bosses that we would actually be going to a coastal town.
Later that morning at the
A few hours later, it was time to get our site assignments. One by one, names were read off and correlating sites were pronounced. As each person was eliminated along with their site, the remaining volunteers quickly recalculated their chances of ending up in a certain province or a certain climate zone. For us, every time a coastal site came up, we were sure our name was going to be read.
A site name was read, the department was Cajamarca. Milene and I barely paid attention because we knew Cajamarca was a mountain department, not a coastal department. Suddenly, our name was read and we jumped to our feet in elation. We were getting a mountain site after all! But the biggest surprise came when we were handed a folder with all the information and pictures of our town. I opened the folder, pulled out the photos and saw our town—on the edge of a lake and surrounded by mountains.
Sure enough, when we arrived at site for site visit, our town sat exactly on the edge of an enormous lake, surrounded by Nevada-like mountains. Our house was one of two homes in the town that was located directly on the lake shore, just as in the dream. During the rainy season, water comes up to the walls of our home, and although we don’t have a porch, we do have a balcony. Oddly enough, as I had dreamed that the town was actually built on the lake, I later found out that the town had previously been located where the lake currently is. The town was only recently relocated further up the mountain when the government installed a hydro-electric dam and flooded the entire valley, giving rise to a new lake exactly where the town used to be. As for the lake which I dreamed was dirty, it was the only part of the dream that seemed flat wrong. The lake was blue and people told me that swimming and water sports were not uncommon there. In any case, I was happy to be wrong about that point and happy that the lake looked so beautiful. It took about a month of being in site until I finally learned that the lake has a problem: all of the town’s sewage is drained directly into it. Now, the lake is miles and miles long, so for now there’s enough water volume for this not to be a serious problem, but it will become serious in the future and this at least explains why I dreamt of a dirty lake.
Upon returning from site visit, no one could believe the photos I showed them—exactly what I had predicted it would be like according to my dream. I still cannot believe the uncanny accuracy of that dream, nor can Milene for that matter. In fact, many of you are probably thinking that I am somehow exaggerating this post to make a better story, but I have about 20 real-live witnesses who will tell you that they heard me explain this exact dream to them hours before I ever found out my site. Whatever the explanation for that dream, I’m just happy that we ended up here, in a place that feels meant to be, a place that feels like home.
Weekend Fun
Last Saturday night, we got our first taste of what “going out on the weekend” is like in our town. Early in the day we met up for lunch with a few teenage girls who have befriended Milene since we’ve arrived here. At lunch they asked us if we wanted to hang out together at night and have some fun. We said yes and agreed to meet at the Plaza around 10. Now, although Milene and I are usually in the habit of going to sleep around 10 or 11 in this quiet town, we thought we’d venture out past our bed time to see what the weekend bustle might be like. Sure enough, as we walked from our house down by the laguna banks up the hill to the central Plaza, we saw a more-than-usual number of people out and about. Things were looking up. It was exciting to see this unusual amount activity in a town with no movie theaters, no bowling alleys, no bars, no late-night stores, and no 24-hour Walmart. Milene and I wondered what our friends had in mind for the get-together.
As we neared the Plaza we saw our friends waiting on one of the benches. They waved eagerly and stood up to greet us. We gave our greetings with a traditional Peruvian kiss on the cheek and sat down on the bench to talk. They asked us many questions and we talked about a variety of things until it came to the point that we thought we might ask our friends if there was something fun they wanted to do together. After all it was a weekend night, and it seemed like there might be a town party somewhere or maybe a soccer game. In any case, we were in the habit of following along and just observing what life was like for people in the town. So it seemed like a great idea when our friends suggested we stroll around the Plaza for a little bit.
Well, as it turns out, strolling around the Plaza is actually the main attraction for weekend fun—for everyone. After making numerous circuitous trips around the Plaza ourselves, we decided to sit down again on one of the benches, all the meanwhile just talking with our friends about this and that. As we continued chatting and sitting, we observed the same groups of friends and couples passing us by on the same well-known ‘Plaza circuit’ as many as 10 or 15 times. People just seemed to be enjoying themselves, doing nothing more than talking and strolling along the same path surrounding the Plaza over and over. We even saw a few of the town cars making the same stroll, but adding a little spice to the evening mix by playing music as they slowly (and I mean very slowly) cruised around the Plaza. Just as we sat on the bench, the cars too interspersed their circuit trips with the occasional stop-and-chill on the side of the road.
As this went on for several hours, Milene and I realized that there really was nothing more to it. This is what people do for fun on the weekends here. They just stroll and talk. Young and old alike do it and everyone doesn’t seem notice that the iPods, the movies, the bars, the video games, every piece of high-tech entertainment, it’s all missing. It’s just not part of their culture of having fun at night and it is so very novel to us. Milene and I laughed in pleasant surprise the whole way home that night, both realizing how tame our ‘going out’ had been. And yet it was nice. It was very nice. When was the last time we spent a few hours on a weekend evening just talking with friends and relaxing? No TV, no cell phones, no technology; just talking and walking? Neither of us could remember. But we both agreed that it is something we’d like to get used to doing here. Just talking and walking. Talking and walking.
Plazas de Armas
As rustic as this type of organization may seem, it still works well to this day. People may not gather with their weapons at the Plaza anymore, but it certainly is a great point of geographical reference for anybody—tourist and resident alike—when traversing the city. Everything can be described in relation to its relative location with the Plaza. Anytime you need to find an important building or agency, chances are its on or near the Plaza. If you ever get lost, just ask people where the Plaza is and you’ll always find your way to where you need to go.
Here’s some of the Plazas de Armas Milene and I have been to while in
Our Town:
Carhuaz, Ancash:
Cajamarca City:
Monday, October 6, 2008
RSS Feeds
Hey Guys,
Anyone who is interested can sign up for RSS feeds which will automatically send you an email every time we put up a post on this blog. It is the orange icon on the right bottom panel of our blog. We’ll probably put up a few posts each month since our internet access is very limited here. But his would allow you to know every time we post something instead of having to frequently check the site and realizing how slow we are at updating!
--Nate and Milene
Saturday, October 4, 2008
Pachamanca -- Peruvian BBQ
Sunday, June 29, 2008
Pictures from the first few weeks
We'll be in touch soon!